Its 2011 and Im making my way through Lordran for the first time.

Im in the woods with my longsword and Grass Crest Shield.

There is a glimmer through the trees and another player appears, wearing exotic equipment.

Dark Souls 3 is a 2016 action RPG from FromSoftware, developers of Elden Ring. Its servers are down again.

I raise my guard, anticipating a swift defeat, but the other player only stands and waves.

They beckon me deeper into the wood.

Its rarely smart to follow a stranger into the woods.

A monstrous cat perched in a window frame in Dark Souls

The second player does not react to my arrival.

The first player gesticulates urgently.

There follows a long, silent exchange of emotes.

A dragon blowing fire in Dark Souls

The first player points at the second, kneeling player.

I spread my arms in bewilderment.

The first player bows, points at the kneeling player and makes chopping motions with their greatsword.

Two sword-wielding human characters fighting a fiery enemy in Elden Ring Nightreign

A willing human sacrifice?

I feel like if I follow the directions there will be a horrible, Basilisk-grade surprise.

But Im also worried that the first player will attack me if I refuse to play along.

They die without protest.

The first player is ecstatic, hopping up and down and punching the air.

I kill them with two-thirds left in my health bar and a full bag of Estus.

I am totally confused.

The fey Covenants you must forge to become a certainkindof online transgressor.

There are forms of multiplayer hidden away in Souls that I never would have guessed, as a newcomer.

And then there is the enchantment of the asynchronous online, which makes every location a little disquieting.

To play Dark Souls is to be haunted by everybody else playing it.

By extension, Im a little worried about the direction of FromSoftwares most recent projects.

Much as you shouldnt follow strangers into the trees, so you shouldnt bet against a FromSoftware game.

I dont doubt that Duskbloods and Nightreign will be good.

They will probably be great.

Yep, this is fantastic.

I will be hoping for buried complications, quirky rites of interaction that take initiative and deduction to expose.

I will be hoping for more randos in the woods.